Work sample · Curriculum design

Sample Unit: Realistic Fiction, Grade 3

A six-week reading and writing unit built with Understanding by Design. Students study how a character's traits shape a story's problem and solution, then write, illustrate and publish their own realistic fiction book.

About this sample

This unit comes from PS 89 in the Bronx, a K-8 school of about 1,200 students. From 2011 to 2013 Nicodemus worked there as an Innovation Consultant with Authentic Education and a certified Understanding by Design trainer, co-designing the school's K-8 curriculum with its teachers and school leaders. The Grade 3 team designed this unit, and he coached the design.

What changed: after three straight years of C's, PS 89 earned an A on its 2012–13 NYC Progress Report.

From the school’s records: PS 89’s May 2013 staff bulletin lists two Authentic Education visit days with Nicodemus for participating teachers. The same bulletin set a schoolwide expectation: every teacher keeps a copy of their current Understanding by Design unit in their plan book, with the essential question, focus question and Common Core standards posted in the room. That year, teachers in other grades and subjects sent him their own UbD units for review.

School yearNYC Progress Report grade
2012–13A (higher than 83% of schools citywide; Student Progress: A)
2011–12C
2010–11C
2009–10C

Source: NYC Department of Education Progress Report data, published on NYC Open Data (2006–2013 Citywide Progress Report). Several partners supported PS 89 in those years. Curriculum design was our part of that work.

Stage 1: Desired results

Big idea: Our personal traits shape how we respond to what happens in our lives.

Transfer goals. Students will be able to, on their own:

  • Tell the difference between what could really happen and what couldn't.
  • Explain how a person's traits affect the way they treat others, and make inferences from those traits.
  • Recognize that people are complex and can have many traits at once.
  • Use what they learned to write their own realistic fiction.

Essential questions

  1. What makes a story realistic fiction?
  2. How can our own experiences help us understand a character's traits?
  3. How do authors create characters and stories that feel real?

Students will know

  • The elements of realistic fiction (characters, setting, problem, solution) and how it differs from other genres
  • Main and secondary characters, and internal and external traits
  • How a character's traits drive what they do (cause and effect)
  • Story structure: beginning, middle and end, with an ending that brings closure
  • How to write dialogue with quotation marks and organize paragraphs

Students will be able to

  • Write a realistic fiction story in which a character's traits shape the problem and the solution
  • Choose precise words and add details and dialogue that bring a character to life
  • Show a character's thoughts and feelings through action
  • Plan with graphic organizers and keep a writer's notebook
  • Revise, edit, illustrate and publish a finished book

Standards (Common Core, Grade 3)

FocusStandard
PrimaryRL.3.3 Describe characters (traits, motivations, feelings) and explain how their actions contribute to the sequence of events.
PrimaryW.3.3 Write narratives using effective technique, descriptive details and clear event sequences: introduce characters, use dialogue and description, use time words, and provide closure.
SupportingRL.3.4, RL.3.5, RL.3.10 Story parts and how they build, how illustrations convey mood and character, and reading grade-level literature independently.
SupportingW.3.4, W.3.5, W.3.10 Writing organized for task and purpose, planning and revising with support, and writing routinely over short and extended time frames.

Stage 2: Assessment evidence

Performance task: Meet the Author

Each student writes and illustrates an original realistic fiction book. The main character's traits must shape both the problem and the solution, and the ending must tie up loose ends. The unit closes with a Meet the Author celebration in the school library. Students talk about their books with classmates, teachers and administrators, and the finished books join the library collection.

ElementDetail
RoleAuthor and illustrator
AudienceClassmates, teachers, school leaders, and future readers in the library
ProductA published, illustrated realistic fiction book
CriteriaCharacter traits drive the problem and solution; vivid details and dialogue; clear beginning, middle and end; an ending with closure; edited for conventions

Other evidence

  • Baseline story, written before instruction from a blank story elements organizer and scored on a standards-based narrative rubric
  • Character sketch of internal and external traits
  • Graphic organizers (six-box character planner, story mountain)
  • Writer's notebook entries and reading response notes

Stage 3: Learning plan

Pre-assessment. Students fill in a blank story elements organizer on their own, then use it to write a short realistic fiction story. The teacher scores it on the narrative rubric to set a baseline and plan small groups.

Hook. "We are going to be authors and illustrators!" Students learn that they will study how real authors build stories around characters, then create a class character and story together before writing their own.

Reading and writing workshop run side by side each day, with a mini-lesson framed as "Good readers..." or "Good writers..."

WeekReading workshopWriting workshop
1. LaunchAuthors write from their own experiences; making text-to-self, text-to-text and text-to-world connections; partner talk; visualizing; asking questionsSetting up a writer's notebook; writing true stories from memory; finding the "seed" in a big "watermelon" idea; rereading entries to add detail; showing thoughts and feelings
2. CharactersKeeping a reading notebook; charting characters' internal and external traits in mentor texts; finding setting, characters, problem and solutionBaseline story; building a class character with the six-box planner; drafting possible problems and solutions for the character
3. Story structureMapping mentor texts on a story mountain; how authors set the scene with the five senses; show, don't tell; dialogue; how authors bring closurePlanning beginning, middle and end on a story mountain; drafting scenes; adding dialogue; writing an ending that ties up loose ends
4. RevisionWord choice that creates imagery; order of events; key events; characters who change and who don't; mood and toneRevising for word choice and detail with a partner and the teacher; editing for conventions on their own, with a partner and with the teacher
5. PublishingReading aloud with expression, punctuation and fluencyIllustrating so pictures support the text; producing the final book
6. CelebrationRehearsing a short author talkMeet the Author celebration in the library; books added to the collection

Vocabulary and mentor texts

Tier 1 (everyday)Tier 2 (academic)Tier 3 (genre-specific)
author, character, predict, actions, feelings, traits, beginning, middle, end memories, entries, sequence, connections, visualizing, plot, climax, cause, effect, compare, contrast, narrator, dialogue, setting, problem, solution internal, external, resolution, mood, tone, mischievous, humorous

Personal narrative mentor texts

  • Patricia Polacco: Thank You, Mr. Falker; My Rotten Redheaded Older Brother; Thunder Cake
  • Cynthia Rylant: The Relatives Came; When I Was Young in the Mountains
  • Jane Yolen: Owl Moon
  • Yangsook Choi: The Name Jar
  • Eric Velasquez: Grandma's Records
  • Judith Viorst: Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day

Realistic fiction mentor texts

  • Cynthia Rylant: Henry and Mudge series
  • Barbara Park: Junie B. Jones series
  • Eve Bunting: Cheyenne Again

Unit designed by the PS 89 Grade 3 team with design coaching from Nicodemus Ford, Authentic Education (2012). Shared as a work sample.

Want curriculum your teachers will actually use?

Nicodemus co-designs units, courses and programs with the people who teach them, from K-12 classrooms to adult and community learning.

Book a call See Co-Design & Strategy